Tag Archives: Group work

Collaborate or Work Alone?

17 Jan

inetgiant.com

I came across an interesting article in the New York Times about the growing tendency toward collaboration in all sectors of society, including education.  Working in groups i.e. “group thinking” is  better than working alone, right?  Not always.

The author, Susan Cain says, “…we need to move beyond the New Groupthink and embrace a more nuanced approach to creativity and learning…Our schools should teach children to work with others, but also to work on their own for sustained periods of time. And we must recognize that introverts …need extra quiet and privacy to do their best work.”  Cain expounds upon the claim that, “research strongly suggests… people are more creative when they enjoy privacy and freedom from interruption. ”  Yet contrary to this theory, it seems that our schools are rallying more and more around the themes and practices of collaboration, group work and group brainstorming sessions.  And not without good reason; there is plenty of existing research to support the move toward more collaboration.

From my experience, it seems more accurate to say that students learn best and are most creative when they are actively engaged in the learning process.  Groups do have the ability to engage students in the learning process, which is why working in groups offers many benefits to a classroom environment.  On the flip side, group work is distracting to some learners and can stifle individual creativity.  As special educators and communication specialists, we know that there is no one size fits all model when it comes to student engagement.  Fostering a breeding ground for learning and creativity requires a highly individualized investigation into each child’s disposition, interests and needs.

Group work and group thinking has its place and in some situations is a crucial aspect of the learning process.  This is especially true when we look at theories of active learners, and the benefits of peer models in early childhood education or when specifically targeting social skills.  But sometimes we do our best work, our best thinking and our creative juices flow most freely when we offer ourselves the time and space to work alone. Uninterrupted. Unconcerned about group pressures and dynamics.  Uninhibited.

For me, the take home message of this article is, like anything else in life, we need a balance.  We need group work and team work to thrive, but we also need solitude and individual time to create, grow and empower.  This is the way we are as humans, and our schools and workplaces should work to preserve this balance, being careful not to get caught up in too much of any one approach.  It takes a master teacher to approach this balance.  Ideally our classrooms and language therapy sessions are a well oiled machine, where all the parts are working together, integrating, and collaborating, yet creativity is not stifled and the capability some students gain from working alone is not overlooked.

Here is the link to the full New York Times Article by Susan Cain:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/15/opinion/sunday/the-rise-of-the-new-groupthink.html

%d bloggers like this: